
We can finally see the light at the end of the renovation tunnel. Granted, it’s still a tad dim, but there’s definitely a hopeful glimmer. Tile work has started in the bathrooms, interior painting is close to complete, floor refinishing began today, concrete for driveway & breezeway begins next week, followed by kitchen & bath cabinet installation. Newly crafted front & gallery doors will be installed after that. Woohoo! Sounds like we’re moving in before the end of the year!
A long, hot summer seemed even longer with reno work at a snail’s pace through August. I won’t bore you with all the work delays. Let’s just say there were many. As a friend said to me in early July, “It always costs twice as much and takes twice as long as you think.” Yep. Sure does.

The good news, however, is that everyone took great pride in their work and has done a quality job on their individual tasks. At the end of the day, this is what will really matter – not the sensation that we stood still and watched paint dry all summer.
You never know what you might encounter when you start tearing away at a 143 year old house. Luckily, we’ve encountered very few ugly surprises along the way. Just one giant scary one. The first and second story galleries looked like they would need some work… UNDERSTATEMENT. Forget what’s rotten in Denmark, the floors, ceilings and columns of these porches were nothing but rot.
The galleries – “before” Rotted gallery ceiling Rotted gallery column Rotted gallery floor The former galleries…

Fortunately, we had applied for and were granted a Preservation & Community Enhancement Grant (P.A.C.E.) through the City of Madison’s Office of Historic Preservation. Our application focused on two projects visible from the street – three new period doors to be custom-made by Welch Millwork & Design (along with refurbishing the accompanying glass transoms), and the “shoring up” of the galleries’ structures by our trimwork team on site. The door and transom work has gone swimmingly, but the galleries had to be completely demolished and rebuilt with appropriate materials to look and function like the originals. Again I say, SCARY.
That said, it turned out to be best case scenario. The trim team had great vision & skill and fashioned gorgeous gallery replacements while seemingly dangling from the side of the building. I know these guys are used to hoisting and balancing, but it looked like Cirque du Soleil to me. I guess that’s why they do what they do, and I stay on the ground. Here is an assortment of photos from the build.
Gallery rebuilding begins… A view from above Buidling the new lower ceiling The new upper ceiling Painted new upper floor Finishing the trim Galleries completely rebuilt – waiting for spindle paint
We really have made great progress this last year. “Slow and steady wins the race.” Ken & I should have t-shirts with that on them. We have “felt” every day of the process, but when we look at “before & after” photos of the project so far, the transformation is quite amazing. I cannot wait to see the REAL “after” photos. Enjoy these pics of the progress journey and stay tuned for The Grand Finale!
Living Room Transformation to Date
Fireplace wall “before” Wallpaper stripped; insulation staging area Walls prepped with bonding agent Finish paint – awaiting floor refinishing
Front door wall “before Finish paint – awating new door & transom
Dining Room Transformation to Date
Fireplace wall – before Wallpaper stripped, bonding agent applied Finish paint, awaiting floor refinishing & new door
Stairway wall – before Wallpaper stripped, bonding agent applied Finish paint, awaiting floor refinishing and new door
Kitchen Transformation to Date
Kitchen east wall – before Caninets removed, new drywall Brick exposed, new poplar floor, finish paint – awaiting floor finishing & cabinets Kitchen west wall – before Brick exposed (mudroom & bath addition beyond)
New Addition to Date. The old existing shed was demolished and a new one story brick addition was added to the rear of the house. It contains a rear entry “mudroom”, coat closet and powder room.
Rear shed – before Additon breezeway entrance Addition, view from breezeway – 1/2 bath left, kitchen right Addition alley view
Master Bedroom, Bath & Closet Transformation to Date
Master Bedrrom – before. Closet left, bath right Closet – before Bath – before
Wallpaper removing, closet/bath framing Closet/bath wall insulation Closet drywalled
Bath floor leveled Closet floor tiled, window trimmed Finish paint, awating floor refinishing
Upstairs Den Transformation to Date
Upsatirs den – before Zinc box “plumbing chase” for master bath Wallpaper removed
Bonding agent applied Finish paint, awaiting floor refinishing Finish paint, awaiting floor refinishing
Guest Room, Bath & Laundry Transformation to Date
Guest room – before – closet left, bath right Bath – before Wallpaper removed, bath framing Bath wall insulation
Bath window, bonding agent applied to walls Bath/laundry wall leveled Floor tiled, shower pan built Finish paint, awaiting floor refinishing
The New Garage & Breezeway Addition Transformation to Date. We were lucky to have a side yard that could accommodate a garage with a connecting breezeway. Ken did a great job with design concept, and the selected handmade brick blended beautifully with the house brick.
Brick delivered for garage Slab poured, materials deliverd Framing completed
Roofing completed Brick work begun


Thanks for taking a look at our 1876 Fixer Upper progress report!
Love all your progress reports. Congratulations on a beautiful new home! I hope to see it in person someday. xo
Thanks, Nicole. It would be great to have you visit!!
wow. Such patience and attention to detail.
Thanks, Nanci! #laboroflove
It looks great, so fun to follow your progress. It’s wonderful to see a historic house done the right way. I can’t wait to see the kitchen finished! Thanks for sharing.
Thanks, Sarah. I’m DYING to see the finished kitchen. I know I’m going to love it.